Lecture by Thomas Schirrmacher in Bern on November 9, 2026, in commemoration of the November pogroms of 1938
Your Excellency Ambassador Tibor Shalev Schlosser,
Dear Rabbi Eliezer di Martino,
Ladies and gentlemen,
“3000 Years of the Jews as Enemies of Humanity, 1700 Years of Replacement Theology”: this title sounds pointed. Unfortunately, historically it is far less exaggerated than one would wish. Today I would like to bring three lines together: the astonishing persistence of antisemitism, the particular responsibility of the Christian churches, and the question of how we can protect Jews and the State of Israel today without abandoning the universal principle of human rights.
I deliberately do so also as a German, in deep shame over the German crimes against the Jewish people, for which the November pogroms – above all November 9, 1938 (at the time euphemistically called “Reichskristallnacht”), which we commemorate today in deep sorrow – were merely the prelude. I also do so as the author of “Hitlers Kriegsreligion” (Hitler’s Religion of War) and as someone who has long been active in the global Jewish-Christian dialogue and in the dialogue of the Abrahamic religions.
First, the historical uniqueness of antisemitism. There are many forms of racism, religious persecution and hostility toward groups of people. But I know of no other religion and no other ethnic community that has been declared an enemy over such a long period of time, in so many cultures, and across such different religions and worldviews as the Jews. That is my central thesis. It does not mean that the suffering of others is any less. It means that, in the case of antisemitism, we have to explain an extraordinary historical continuity.
Long before the emergence of Christianity and Islam we encounter anti-Jewish stereotypes. The Egyptian author Manetho in the third century BC, and later Roman writers such as Tacitus and Juvenal, portrayed the Jews as a people that set itself apart from all others, resisted the order of the state and was hostile toward other human beings. The accusation is not simply: this or that Jewish person has done something wrong. It is: this people is by its very nature a danger to the rest of humanity.
Precisely here lies a key. Antisemitism often needs no real Jews at all. It flourishes even where hardly any Jews live. It explains very different evils by the same supposed cause. The Jewish people becomes a projection screen for whatever a society cannot understand about itself or does not want to admit.
And the images travel through the centuries. Juvenal mocked the Jews by linking them to the pig. The medieval depictions of the so-called “Judensau” (“Jew sow”) on churches are not simply an isolated medieval aberration. They stand within a long history of degradation. The same is true of the accusations that Jews poisoned wells, murdered Christian children or used blood for religious rites. These accusations were false; nevertheless, they were told again and again. As late as the end of the 19th century, ritual murder legends were defended in Christian publications.
What is historically unique about this, in my view, is that precisely the three religious and ideological traditions that have shaped world history most strongly agreed in their hostility toward Jews: Christianity, Islam and the secular ideologies that emerged from the Christian-shaped world. All three have produced widespread forms of antisemitism. The justifications changed, but again and again the same people was declared the enemy. And the different forms by no means remained separate. They borrowed motifs from one another and combined into new forms of hatred of Jews. That one people and its religion were declared the enemy over centuries by such different worldviews has no parallel in history.
This brings us to a painful question: How could a religion whose founder was a Jew, whose apostles were Jews and whose Holy Scripture consists to a considerable extent of the sacred scriptures of Israel become one of the great carriers of anti-Judaism?
Already in the early church a body of literature developed that is referred to as “Adversus Judaeos,” writings against the Jews. In them, the dispute over the interpretation of Scripture increasingly turned into a verdict on an entire people. Christianity, it was said, was now the true Israel; by rejecting Jesus, the Jews had forfeited their place in the plan of salvation; God’s promises had passed to the church. Such ideas appear in various forms in the works of major Christian authors. One need not reject the Church Fathers wholesale in order to say that it was precisely their authority that reinforced the anti-Jewish tradition.
Replacement theology (in German, “Ersatztheologie”) is therefore not merely an abstract doctrinal opinion. If the church takes the place of Israel and Israel appears only as a rejected people, this also changes the way living Jewish people are seen. A theological distinction easily turns into social exclusion. History shows how often this step was actually taken.
Here I would like to make an excursus on the Council of Nicaea 1700 years ago, which the churches of the world commemorated last year. I want to make an explicit distinction: the Christological confession of Nicaea, which confesses Jesus Christ as truly divine, is for me a great common heritage of Christianity. My criticism is not directed against this confession. It is directed against the anti-Jewish demarcation that becomes particularly evident in the context of the council.
The separation of the church from its Jewish roots had begun long before 325. The originally Jewish Jesus movement had long since become a predominantly non-Jewish church. But at Nicaea, and above all in the imperial communication about the date of Easter, the break becomes visible in a shocking way. The celebration of the resurrection was to be regulated independently of the Jewish calculation of Passover. The calendar alone could have been discussed objectively. Emperor Constantine, however, justified the separation with disparaging statements about the Jews and demanded that Christians have nothing in common with them.
What a tragedy: the church celebrates the resurrection of a Jewish Messiah and in doing so wants to have as little as possible to do with the Jewish people! The memory of the Jewish roots does not merely fade; the demarcation acquires religious and political force. Jewish-Christian communities, which still existed at that time, become increasingly invisible in the church’s grand account of itself.
Nicaea did not invent anti-Judaism. And not every later anti-Jewish development can be derived from a council decision. But the handling of Passover and Constantine’s language are a striking symbol of how the church cut itself off from the history of Israel. Anyone who wants to celebrate the unity of Christians must also face this history.
One might expect the Reformation to have corrected this course. It opposed many wrong developments in church history, it promoted the study of Hebrew, and it placed the Bible at the center. The Old Testament in particular could have been a strong counterweight to contempt for the Jews. And indeed there were important positive approaches in the Reformation tradition.
All the more distressing is the example of Martin Luther. His attitude toward the Jews changed drastically over the course of his life. His late writings on the Jews are among the darkest texts in the history of the Reformation. In “On the Jews and Their Lies” of 1543 he called for measures against synagogues, Jewish homes and religious writings. In “Vom Schem Hamphoras” (On the Ineffable Name), also from 1543, he took up the Wittenberg “Judensau” and intensified the vilification in an almost unbearable manner.
Luther must not be reduced to these texts, nor may they be treated as a marginal note. What is decisive is this: a reformer who championed Holy Scripture against wrong developments in the church could at the same time take up centuries-old anti-Jewish stereotypes and intensify them. Appealing to the Bible alone does not immunize against antisemitism.
The story continues. In the 19th century we encounter new forms of disparagement, now presenting themselves as scholarly. In certain currents of historical-critical theology, the Old Testament was portrayed as though Jewish priests had constructed the tradition for their own purposes and created a narrow, legalistic religious system. This was gladly contrasted with a supposedly higher, freer Christianity. But scholarly methods, too, are applied by people with prejudices. Where the results follow from the outset the pattern that what is Jewish is legalistic, narrow and inferior and what is Christian is free and universal, old polemics have been dressed in new academic garb.
Conservative and evangelical Christians, too, should not be quick to exonerate themselves. Anyone who recognizes the Old Testament as God’s Word does have an important theological reason to take Israel seriously. But even in Israel-friendly theological systems, problematic notions about Jews and their future role can live on; for the insiders, I will merely mention the theologian Erich Sauer by way of a keyword. What is decisive is not the label of a theological school, but whether we respect Jewish people as human beings and present the Jewish roots of the Christian faith truthfully.
The next surprising development is that antisemitism by no means remained bound to religion. Secular nationalism, racist ideologies and political conspiracy theories took over old images and reshaped them. Under National Socialism it no longer mattered whether a person held the Jewish faith, had been baptized or had lived as a Christian for generations. Ascribed descent was enough. Even where Christian circles defended baptized Jews, unbaptized Jews all too often remained outside their field of vision.
In Islam, in turn, there were older traditions of anti-Jewish demarcation of its own. Later, European conspiracy narratives were added, which were spread and reinterpreted in the Middle East. The question of whether a particular prejudice was originally Christian, Islamic or secular is important for historians. For the threatened Jewish person, what matters first is that it be fought. Origin explains a hatred; it does not excuse it.
Today we are witnessing these strands mixing once again. Religious images, conspiracy theories and political slogans meet, especially since October 7, 2023. This brings me to Israel-related antisemitism.
Of course one may criticize Israeli governments. One may examine and condemn military decisions, laws and human rights violations. A state is not identical with its government, and no state is above the law.
The working definition of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, the IHRA, rightly reminds us that the State of Israel, too, conceived as a Jewish collectivity, can become the target of antisemitic hostility. At the same time, it states that criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against other countries is not antisemitic for that reason alone. It is this distinction that matters to me.
The line from classical antisemitism to today’s hostility toward Israel becomes especially tangible where it is no longer a government that is being criticized, but the State of Israel that is denied its right to exist in principle. The slogan “From the river to the sea” is used in different ways; where it means the abolition of Israel as a Jewish state, this crossing of the line becomes visible. Then it is no longer only about what Israel does, but about the claim that Israel must not exist.
Compare this with North Korea. Those who criticize the North Korean dictatorship, who condemn its oppression and its human rights violations, do not normally conclude that North Korea must disappear or that North Koreans have no right to political self-determination. In the case of Israel, however, real or alleged injustice is again and again used to derive the demand that the Jewish state as such must be eliminated. That is a striking double standard. And where Jewish people all over the world are held responsible for Israel’s policies, the old notion returns that the Jews as a collective are the guilty ones.
Here one must distinguish carefully: borders, constitutional orders and the future of two peoples can be the subject of political dispute. Not every demand for a different political order is already hatred of Jews. But anyone who denies Jews as a collective the right to security and self-determination, or who accepts their expulsion and deprivation of rights, has crossed the line into inhumanity.
We are not demanding special rights for Jews. We are demanding that Jewish people be treated as we expect for any other ethnic community and any other religious community.
The same applies to Israel. We are not demanding special rights for Israel. We are demanding that Israel be judged and treated by the same standards as any other state in the world. Israel need not be handled with kid gloves. Its government and its policies must face the same criticism as any other government. But the idea of making Israel a scapegoat, or even of calling its existence as a state into question, must not even appear on the horizon.
I would like to close with a conviction that matters to me particularly at an event against antisemitism. Religious freedom is not a special right for people we like, nor is it a special right for the religion to which we ourselves belong. It is a human right for all: for Jews, Muslims, Christians, members of other religions and people without religion. The same applies to human dignity, physical integrity, freedom of expression and protection from discrimination.
That is why I once proposed a thought experiment: What happens if we apply the basic ideas of the IHRA definition, mutatis mutandis, to hostility toward Muslims and hostility toward Christians? Much of it can be transferred without difficulty. Muslims and Christians, too, must not be attacked because of their religion. Criticism of states with a Muslim or Christian majority population, too, must not turn into hatred of all Muslims or all Christians.
I do not say this in order to relativize antisemitism. On the contrary. The fact that human rights apply to all in no way weakens my central historical finding: no other religion and no other ethnic community has been, and is being, declared the universal enemy in a comparable way, over such a long time and in so many different worldviews, as the Jewish people.
Precisely for this reason we must hold both together: the resolute, especially vigilant fight against antisemitism and the undivided validity of human rights. We must not fight the exclusion of some by looking away from the exclusion of others. And we must not remain silent about the uniqueness of the history of antisemitism merely because human rights are universal.
For the churches, this also means self-examination. It is not enough to condemn antisemitism today if we do not recognize its traces in our own theology and history. For society, it means not merely honoring Jewish life in lofty speeches, but guaranteeing its security and freedom in practice. And for all of us, it means opposing every attempt to make a people, a religion or a state the alleged enemy of humanity.
Thank you very much.