Mastodon Musical Instruments and Music of a High Standard from the Very Beginning – Thomas Paul Schirrmacher
 
 

Retracting and Confirming My 1979 Article

This article replaces my piece “Music: Evolution or Creation?,” Creation Research Society Quarterly 16 (1979/80) 1 (Jun 1979): 73–74+84 (original article as PDF), reprinted in: Thomas Schirrmacher, Legends About the Galileo-Affair, RVB: Hamburg, 2001 (1st ed.), 2008 (2nd ed.), pp. 47–52 (collected volume as PDF). German version: “Musik — Evolution oder Schöpfung?” [“Music — Evolution or Creation?”], Factum 5+6 (1982), pp. 30–32; reprinted in: Thomas Schirrmacher, Galilei-Legenden und andere Beiträge zur Schöpfungsforschung und zur Chronologie der Kulturgeschichte 1979–1994 [Galileo Legends and Other Contributions to Creation Research and the Chronology of Cultural History, 1979–1994], VKW: Bonn, 1995, ISBN 978-3-926105-58-5, pp. 164–171.

Preliminary Note

In 1979, I published an article on the evolutionary history of music. It is completely outdated in content, method, and state of research. It relied on the state of knowledge in musicology and archaeology at the time, which has since been superseded by numerous new finds, improved dating methods, and a fundamentally changed discussion of human origins. I am, in effect, retracting most of the individual claims made in the old text.

The core thesis, by contrast, has remained remarkably stable and has, if anything, been reinforced by newer finds: The oldest known musical instruments and the earliest evidence of music are by no means primitive; rather, from the very beginning and everywhere, they are astonishingly advanced both technically and acoustically — as true of the oldest finds, fifty thousand years ago, as of the dawn of the high cultures of the third millennium. Archaeologically, there is no discernible “precursor stage” of simple, unmusical noise-making from which music gradually developed. Wherever musical instruments appear in the record, they appear as fully conceived, functioning instruments, often capable of several tones.

One methodological point from my old article still holds: the mere order in which instruments are arranged in tables or collections does not, by itself, suggest a development. A newer or technically more complex instrument is not automatically a “further development” of a simpler one, and in many places older instruments continued to be used alongside newer ones rather than being replaced by them.

A Note on My Qualifications and the Scope of This Article

I have no professional expertise in paleoanthropology, prehistoric archaeology, or music archaeology. I can therefore only gather here what specialists in the field have published, and in particular I adopt the dates given there directly from the relevant specialist literature, without being able to assess them myself. I neither can nor wish to render my own judgment on the reliability of individual dating methods or on disputed points of detail (for example, whether a given find is actually an instrument or merely the result of chance).

Despite this limitation, the overall picture across all finds, regions, and periods is strikingly consistent: wherever musical instruments appear in the archaeological record, they appear already fully developed.

The Divje Babe flute, a perforated cave-bear bone from the Divje Babe I cave (Slovenia) © CC BY-SA 4.0, photo: Petar Milošević, via Wikimedia Commons

The Earliest Evidence for Musical Instruments and Music

Without claiming to be exhaustive, in roughly chronological order:

The Oldest Music: Ice-Age Flutes (c. 60,000–20,000 Years Ago)

  • Divje Babe Flute, Slovenia (at least 50,000 years old) — a perforated cave-bear bone from the Divje Babe I cave, found in 1995, from a Middle Paleolithic (Mousterian) layer. Depending on the source, dated to roughly 50,000 to 60,000 years ago, making it older than the arrival of modern humans in Europe. Usually attributed to Neanderthals, though this remains disputed among specialists to this day (some regard the holes as bite marks left by predators rather than deliberate boring).
  • Geißenklösterle, Swabian Jura, Germany (at least 42,000 years old) — flutes made from swan bone and from mammoth ivory. A renewed high-resolution radiocarbon dating in 2012 placed them at roughly 42,000 to 43,000 years old. The ivory flute is especially remarkable, since the ivory had to be split lengthwise, hollowed out, and rejoined — an elaborate manufacturing process.
  • Hohle Fels, Swabian Jura, Germany (at least 35,000 years old) — an almost completely preserved flute made from the radius bone of a griffon vulture, found in 2008, with five finger holes and a V-shaped notch cut into the mouthpiece. Dated to roughly 35,000 to 40,000 years ago. Regarded as the best-preserved Ice-Age instrument of all.
  • Isturitz, Pyrenees, France (at least 20,000 years old) — several vulture-bone flutes from various Upper Paleolithic layers, with dates ranging from roughly 35,000 to 20,000 years ago, documenting a musical tradition that persisted for thousands of years within the same cave system.

Jiahu — The Transition to Neolithic Musical Culture

  • Jiahu, Henan Province, China (at least 7,700 years old) — more than 30 flutes made from the ulna of the red-crowned crane, six of them fully intact, with five to eight finger holes, from an Early Neolithic settlement. Dated to roughly 7000 to 5700 BC (about 9,000–7,700 years old). One of the best-preserved flutes has been played again; its scale comes astonishingly close to the Western eight-note scale. Regarded as the world’s oldest still-playable, multi-tone musical instrument.

One of the bone flutes from Jiahu, China, made from the ulna of the red-crowned crane © CC BY-SA 2.0, photo: asgitner (Flickr), via Wikimedia Commons

Early High Cultures: The Onset of a Long, Continuous Musical Culture

  • Mesopotamia, Third Millennium BC — this is probably the earliest continuously attested musical culture, with depictions of instruments that influenced painting and religion. The famous lyres and harps of Ur also belong to this period. Also noteworthy is an observation by the music ethnologist Kurt Reinhard: toward the end of the Sumerian period, around 2000 BC, harps almost completely disappear from the pictorial record while large frame drums take their place — even though drums are demonstrably much older than the mature stringed instruments. This shows that a reliable developmental sequence cannot simply be read off from the order in which images happen to survive.
  • China, c. 2300 BC — written evidence of an elaborate music theory with a mathematically calculated tone system; music was part of the required education of every scholar.
  • India, Third Millennium BC — evidence of more than twenty different instruments and a complex tone system, with no discernible preceding “primitive” stage of development.
  • Egypt, from the Third Millennium BC — evidence of large, state-maintained orchestras.
  • Hurrian Cult Hymn from Ugarit, Syria (c. 3,400 years old) — the oldest known written-down melody complete with notation, on a clay tablet from the 14th century BC, with tuning instructions for a lyre.

Lyres from the Royal Cemetery of Ur, Mesopotamia © CC BY-SA, Foto: Iazyges, via Wikimedia Commons

Overview of the Finds

Site Find Age (approx.) Material / Notable Feature
Divje Babe, Slovenia Bone flute 50,000–60,000 years Cave-bear bone; probably Neanderthal; attribution disputed
Geißenklösterle, Germany Flutes 42,000–43,000 years Swan bone and mammoth ivory
Hohle Fels, Germany Flute 35,000–40,000 years Vulture bone, 5 finger holes, nearly complete
Isturitz, France Several flutes 35,000–20,000 years Vulture bone; tradition documented over millennia
Jiahu, China Over 30 flutes 9,000–7,700 years Crane bone, playable, up to 8 finger holes
Mesopotamia Lyres, harps (e.g., Ur) c. 4,500–4,000 years Oldest continuous musical culture, with religious associations
China Music theory (written) c. 4,300 years Mathematically calculated tone system
Ugarit, Syria Hurrian cult hymn c. 3,400 years Oldest surviving melody with notation

Conclusion

However cautious one must be about individual dates and attributions, the overall trend across nearly 60,000 years of archaeological record is remarkably consistent: musical instruments never appear in the archaeological record in a recognizably primitive initial form, but from the outset as carefully conceived, functioning tools, in some cases capable of several tones. That was already the core thesis of my article in 1979 — the only difference is that most of the finds on which this conclusion now rests had not yet been discovered at the time.

PDF-Download
Permalink